Plan. Protect. Pass It On.

  1. Home
  2.  » 
  3. Firm News
  4.  » Is ChatGPT a Good Alternative to Hiring a Lawyer?

Is ChatGPT a Good Alternative to Hiring a Lawyer?

by | Dec 4, 2023 | Firm News

In today’s digital age, it’s tempting to embrace the convenience of artificial intelligence (AI) and online legal forms for handling legal matters. After all, who wouldn’t be drawn to the allure of quick, easy, and often cheaper alternatives to traditional legal services? But as enticing as these options might seem, they’re not without significant pitfalls, especially for non-experts. Think of it this way: having access to a plumber’s toolkit doesn’t magically bestow upon you the skills of a plumber. You might end up turning a small leak into a flood! If you are an expert on the subject matter being handled, you may be equipped to work from online templates or to draft your own documents with ChatGPT or other A.I. If you are a novice, however, please beware.

The Allure of AI and Online Forms

First, let’s acknowledge the elephant in the room: AI and online legal templates can be incredibly useful, especially for legal professionals. They offer a starting point, streamline processes, and can save time and effort. In the hands of an expert, these tools are like a high-tech scalpel – precise and efficient. But in the hands of a novice? Well, let’s just say it’s more like performing surgery with shaky hands.

The Dangers of DIY Legal Work Using AI or Online Forms

1. The Illusion of Correctness
AI-generated legal documents can look incredibly convincing. They use the right jargon, the formatting is spot on, and they often cover a lot of legal bases. But appearances can be deceiving. Without the trained eye of a legal professional, you might not catch the nuances or the missing elements that could turn a seemingly perfect document into a legal minefield. A document generated through AI is only going to be as good as the inputs you made, and if you don’t know what you’re talking about, you’re not going to know the right inputs.

2. One Size Fits None
Legal templates are just that – templates. They’re designed to be broadly applicable, which often means they’re not tailored to your unique situation. Just as a one-size-fits-all hat is likely to fit few people perfectly, a generic legal document is unlikely to cover all the specifics of your case. A template is an outline, but it’s not a finished product.

3. You Don’t Know What You Don’t Know
This is perhaps the biggest hazard. Without a background in law, it’s tough to know what you’re missing. It’s not just about filling in the blanks; it’s about understanding what those blanks represent. Using AI or a template without this understanding is like trying to navigate a maze blindfolded – you might make
some right turns, but you’re just as likely to hit a dead end.

The Value of Professional Expertise

The real value of a legal professional lies not just in their ability to draft documents, but in their experience, perspective, and understanding of the law. If you are dealing with an issue in the lawyer’s area of expertise, they can foresee potential problems, tailor solutions to your specific needs, and navigate the complex legal landscape on your behalf. A lawyer should be an advisor, not just a document preparer. The error many people make is thinking they’re just hiring a lawyer to create a document that is easy to pull off the Internet. If that’s the type of lawyer you’re used to having, maybe you should look for a true advisor.

1. Perspective and Experience
An experienced attorney can spot issues you might not even consider. They can predict potential pitfalls and navigate around them, saving you from future headaches (and potentially, hefty legal fees).

2. Customized Solutions
Every legal situation is unique. A professional can provide tailored advice and documents that reflect your specific circumstances, goals, and concerns.

3. Peace of Mind
There’s a certain peace of mind that comes with knowing your legal matters are in the hands of someone who knows what they’re doing. It’s like having a seasoned captain at the helm of your ship, steering you through stormy legal waters.

In the world of legal services, AI and online templates are valuable tools, but they’re just that – tools. I say that as someone who often uses AI or templates to give me a head start on projects. However, the original product of AI always needs substantial review and revision by me to meaningfully assist my client. AI and templates can help experts deliver services more efficiently, but they’re not a substitute for expertise itself. So, before you dive into the DIY approach, ask yourself: are you really prepared to play legal Russian roulette with your important legal matters? Are you experienced enough in the subject matter to rely upon online-generated forms? If you are outside of your wheelhouse, it’s better to leave it to the professionals.

Final Thought
Remember, in law, as in life, sometimes what you don’t know can hurt you. So, let the experts handle the legal heavy lifting while you focus on what you do best. Even within the legal profession, lawyers have their particular areas of skill and expertise. For example, I would not be smart to handle my own Worker’s Comp case, even if I am a lawyer. It might cost a bit more upfront, but hiring a lawyer who is an expert in your matter could save you a fortune in the long run. Plus, you’ll avoid the awkwardness of explaining to a judge that your legal strategy was based on a template you found online – trust me, that’s one courtroom drama you want to avoid!